The 7 Questions You Should Never Ask During An Informational Interview

My postdoc tenure was ending soon but with no possibility of an extension. As a result, the stakes were high and the mere anticipation of the unemployment situation gave me chills. To make matters worse, all I was able to hear from the people around me were unhelpful advice, while information and help were all that I needed. 

It was frustrating enough to not have a prospective job, but not knowing my industry fit was even more disheartening. Upon scrolling down job postings, I saw that there were several job profiles that I was unaware of.

I knew everything about academic job titles and responsibilities but I had no idea about industry job titles, roles, or expectations. I couldn’t differentiate one industry career from another. Consequently, I felt that I had no potential of adding value to any industry. Above all, I desperately needed a job.

I was eventually introduced to the concept of informational interviews, which comprises networking with industry professionals and ranges from a 5-minute call to a zoom meeting or an in-person sit-down. These contacts provide first-hand information about the industry, job title, and your fitness for the role. 

Informational interviews provide information about the left over company budgets and industry jobs that have not been posted yet. Having these focussed conversations with other professionals helps me comprehend specifics of the job market and make new contacts, such as the hiring managers at the companies I aspired to join. 

This information was pivotal in helping set up my transition strategy and land my first industry job. 

What Is An Informational Interview & How To Set One Up

The purpose of an informational interview is to help you gain the insider information that would help you get a referral and/or land you a job at your target company. Identifying the right person and setting up an informational interview are the preliminary, yet crucial steps in the entire process. 

Informational interviews have to be carefully scripted, smartly executed and piously followed up for these to be helpful and preferably end up as referrals. 

Often PhDs struggle with this first step as they are uncertain where to begin, whom to ask, and how to best use their time to set up an interview.

The best way to get up to speed with informational interviews is to ask people you already know; reach out to established connections. 

At the same time, you should be mindful in your informational interview questions and avoid the common mistakes that generally PhDs make

  • PhDs ask too soon without adding value.
  • PhDs don’t generally clarify the topic to be discussed or the time needed.
  • PhDs often interrogate as lawyers rather than being journalists with some plausible questions.
  • PhDs don’t set  proper expectations or follow up professionally.

Asking for something without adding value is detrimental. Result oriented PhDs tend to ask for things without thinking how the relationship is helping the other person.  You should add value until the relationship feels balanced enough for an informational interview. 

You can add value by talking about their work or their recent promotion/ a publication; don’t make this about you. Informational interviews are strictly about the person you interview with, they are the star of the conversation. 

It is also imperative to respect the professional’s time. So, gently ask for a limited amount of time and inform ahead about the nature of questions you plan on asking them. The tone must be informal yet within boundaries. 

The main aspect of an informational interview is that you build up a relationship with the industry professional and add value to them so that down the road you will have a valued referral.

Setting Up An Informational Interview 

To set up an informational interview, reach out to established connections through email or LinkedIn, build up rapport with them prior to the interview and follow up with them after the interview. Use proper email etiquette, be brief, accurate but first add value. Be sure to make time and topic- dependent questions, respect their time. Set proper expectations and follow up professionally.

Polite, short, to the point, email etiquette enhances your chances of getting a response.

Here’s a professional script to request an informational interview:

Hi [Name],

I found your profile on LinkedIn during my search for an XYZ position/company. I am interested in learning more about XYZ position/company and would value your opinion. Do you have time for a brief 5-minute chat?

Thank you!

[Your Name]

P.S. [Insert compliment, such as, “I love the quote you have on your LinkedIn profile!”]

Every informational interview begins by adding value and must end in a valued relationship with the prospects to end up with a referral. 

The 5 Informational Interview Questions You Should Ask 

1. How did you prepare for the job position?

This category of informational interview questions aim at encouraging the professional to talk about their personal experience with respect to the job search and the hiring process. Informational interview questions like, “What does the onboarding process look like?” provide valuable insight into the application process, qualifications and skills; the company profile, interview process and effective resume style. All the valuable information that you need to show employers you are a competitive candidate. Reminding them of how important referrals have been for their career may encourage them to offer to do the same for you. They may even give a few other names of people at the company to reach out to.

2. What are your current responsibilities? 

These are questions about the company and how your contact interacts with the rest of the company. You can get similar information by asking questions like: “What do you currently do in the company, “Where do you fit in the company?” “What does a typical day or week look like?” “ hours a week do you spend in meetings?” “What are your current responsibilities and deliverables?” “How much would I need to collaborate is needed in the current role?” Current fit questions aim at assessing your fit to that particular job or company.

3. What does the career trajectory look like?

Future fit questions that show your involvement in the career path. Everyone wants to know when their promotion is due, how they can progress in their job so you should ask questions to check your future fit at the company. “Where have others in this position gone after x years? What does the future look like? What are your goals?” You can potentially discover new career opportunities and new directions for your own career path.

4. What is the company culture like?   

These company fit questions are crucial in showing that you understand the importance of the overall company framework. Informational interview questions like: “What is the prevalent hierarchy at the company? How many meetings do you have on a typical day? How do the current company employees communicate with each other on a quotidian basis?” This last question holds utmost importance in the pandemic since most workforces are decentralized. Company fit questions will inform you of how fit you are and what other attributes or skills you need to attain. Salary and bonus questions are strictly off limits.

5. How is the work environment?

These lifestyle questions will give you a bird’s eye view into the way the company works and especially what your job title demands. These informational interview questions also open the window to beyond career queries such as hobbies and interests, which builds the foundation to a stronger more personal and memorable relationship. Informational interview questions like: What is the work life balance at the company? Are people required to report in on the weekends? How many hours a day do people typically work? Is there a lot of travel involved in the position? reveal a lot about the company and the specific role.

Informational interviews open a window into the company, the job position, the culture,  and most importantly how you fit in there, but there are several questions which foil your chances of getting a referral.

7 Questions You Should Never Ask In An Informational Interview

Good informational interview skills go a long way in aiding your job search but bad informational interview questions will instantly weed your chances out. 

Professionals work on a tight schedule with little or no time to spare. Therefore make the most out of the limited time that you have in gathering the information but in the right way.

Choice of words, phrasing, and timing become cardinal in the success of an informational interview. 

1. Can you review my resume and give me suggestions on how to improve it?

Industry professionals are busy. So, unless they ask for it or you have reached a comfortable stage with them, don’t bring in your resume. If you bring the resume early in the conversation, you clearly send the message that you are not interested in their opinions or advice: your main motive is to get your resume through. This negatively impacts your image. 

Once you have attained a certain level of comfort, you can do small questions like, “can I share my resume with you, I was curious if it has the right format? Or can you check if I added the right skills for this job?” At this point, they will gladly take a minute to review your resume.

2. Do you know which companies or positions would best suit me?

An industry professional can give you information about that particular industry and the specific skill set needed for that job title. Beyond this, it’s just speculation as they are unaware of your specific skills, talents, and situation. PhDs do your research and analyze your strength; this question intimates your lack of self confidence to the contact. You need to develop enough confidence to make your own decisions. 

3. What is your salary and bonus? How much money do you make?

Although this may sound logical, it is still a very personal question. It would present you as the pushy kind.  You can say something like: “I have done some research online, and it seems that the typical salary range is x-y, just wanted to confirm if the public information site can be trusted for my future job searches,” is better placed than bluntly asking “How much money do you make?”

4. What specific interview questions were you asked when you applied for your position?

This is information gathering, not a job interview. While a little prodding may put you out as curious, excessive pestering will imply that you don’t value the person’s opinion. It may appear that you were ‘tricking’ them into an interview. Don’t be impatient; wait untill you are asked if you would be interested in applying for a job at their concern, which is fine—as long as it’s their idea, not yours.

5. What new products is your company working on?

Avoid asking intrusive questions. Firstly, you must remember that the industry contact may feel uncomfortable sharing the private details which have no impact on hiring. Therefore, you can rephrase this question to have a better response. For instance ask something like:, “The pandemic has inspired several companies to invest in vaccines, did that impact your company’s goal?”  

6. Can you introduce me to xyz people?

This question is also a timing/word choice-based question, the problem here is asking for a specific introduction during an informational interview. Instead, save this question and keep it vague: “Is there anyone else you could introduce me to who could tell me more about the company?”

7. Can you help me get a job?

Don’t ask for a job, rather ask for advice. This request can certainly result in foiling your chances of getting into the industry through that contact. 

Know your value as a PhD, leverage your skills to get better  instead of settling down for less. Job hunt is specifically the candidate’s responsibility, such a question would put too much pressure on the person speaking with you. Asking for a job will definitely be a big turnoff to someone who is trying to help you already therefore refrain from it. 

Concluding Remarks

In conclusion, informational interviews are the key to a world of the exclusive information, if used wisely they can lead to many job referrals. Relationship matters, therefore aim at building a cordial relation with your contact so that you will remain in their good memories. Add value, choose your words wisely, always follow-up, and use the informational interview tool to your advantage.

If you’re ready to start your transition into industry, you can apply to book a free Transition Call with our founder Isaiah Hankel, PhD or one of our Transition Specialists. Apply to book a Transition Call here.

Book a Transition Call
Get Free Job Search Content Weekly

ABOUT ALEJANDRA VIVIESCAS, PHD

Alejandra holds a PhD in genetics. After finishing her graduate studies, she followed her passion for closing the communication gap between scientific researchers and the general public. Currently, as vice-president of development at Cheeky Scientist, she produces content that helps PhDs find success outside academia.

Alejandra Viviescas, PhD

Similar Articles

5 Miscalculations That Are Holding You Hostage In Academia

5 Miscalculations That Are Holding You Hostage In Academia

By: Isaiah Hankel, PhD

As a PhD student, I felt more and more lost the closer I came to graduation. That’s because I had started to doubt that I knew what I wanted anymore. You could say I was torn, but that would be an understatement. I was absolutely wracked with indecision. My original plan had been to continue on in academia.  I was going to apply for a postdoc.  Then on to Assistant Professor.  And so on. However, I was starting to see a real pattern emerge among the PhD graduates I knew. I liked to check in periodically with those colleagues and…

Is Your Body Language Costing You The Job?

Is Your Body Language Costing You The Job?

By: Isaiah Hankel, PhD

I ran into an old colleague a few days ago – literally. We actually collided going into the same coffee shop.  As luck would have it, we both had some time to kill, so we took a seat and started visiting. I told him all about the work I do, connecting PhDs with the strategies to get hired in industry.  He’d since gone on to work in human resources as a manager at one of the Global 500. We talked about things we wish we’d known after graduation – the importance of things like networking and creating a powerful resume…

Best Of Transition: Ph.D. Jobs & Job Search Strategies January 7, 2023

Best Of Transition: Ph.D. Jobs & Job Search Strategies January 7, 2023

By: Isaiah Hankel, PhD

Every week, we at Cheeky Scientist scour the Internet for the best articles on topics that help in the search for the Best of Transition: PhD Job Search in the industry. Our two consultants independently search for the most informative articles in the categories of networking, CVs/resumes, interviews, transferable skills, academic blues, industry positions, and business acumen. Our consultants vote on a top article for each category and a top overall article for the week – if it’s a recent article that can help readers find and acquire PhD jobs, then we want to include it in this weekly digest.…

Is Cheeky Scientist A Scam? Who Shouldn't Join The Association

Is Cheeky Scientist A Scam? Who Shouldn't Join The Association

By: Isaiah Hankel, PhD

Is Cheeky Scientist a scam?   Has anyone here had any experience with the Cheeky Scientist Association? Is Cheeky Scientist worth it?  What’s the deal with Cheeky Scientist? Is Cheeky Scientist legit? PhDs are trained to be critical.  In academia and in life, every decision they’re faced with is made with extreme prejudice. Examining facts, collecting resources, and determining what is a trustworthy source of information is one of their biggest strengths.  PhDs have superior critical thinking skills, so it makes sense for them to carefully consider any investment – even if it’s an investment in themselves. And in almost every…

4 Red-Hot Intellectual Property Positions For PhDs

4 Red-Hot Intellectual Property Positions For PhDs

By: Isaiah Hankel, PhD

I just got off the phone with an old friend of mine.  We were researchers at the same lab back in our university days. We had lost touch, but when he found me on LinkedIn I couldn’t wait to hear what he’s done since graduation.  He told me he had not wound up in chemistry, which had been his major. Biomolecular chemistry, he reminded me. Instead, he decided to pursue a career in patent law.  Here’s his transition story: I was in the process of earning my PhD in biomolecular chemistry. That’s where I learned that patents were unrecognized by…

Should You Delete Your PhD From Your Resume? The Answer May Surprise You

Should You Delete Your PhD From Your Resume? The Answer May Surprise You

By: Isaiah Hankel, PhD

If you have a PhD, you’re overqualified for an industry job. PhDs are lab rats and can’t understand business. You can’t get a job without industry experience. Do any of these sentences sound familiar to you? Have you been looking for an industry job unsuccessfully and have reached a point where you ask yourself if your PhD has any value whatsoever? These sentences are myths, commonly said by either academics who don’t understand anything about industry, or by other job candidates who don’t want to compete with PhDs. Hiring managers for PhD-level industry positions want the best candidates possible. After…

4 Skills PhDs Have That Employers Are Desperately Seeking

4 Skills PhDs Have That Employers Are Desperately Seeking

By: Isaiah Hankel, PhD

The number of PhDs wanting to transition out of academia increases every year. Initially, most of these PhDs were recent graduates and postdocs.  But as the crisis in academia has gotten worse, we are seeing a lot of adjunct and even tenured professors wanting to leave. They feel professionally unfulfilled in academic positions because they are overworked, work in uninspiring roles, and/or are paid marginal academic stipends, fellowships, and wages.  Far too many PhDs are unable to find any meaning or joy in their academic careers, which negatively impacts both their professional and personal lives. Unfortunately, many of these PhDs end up…

The Exciting (or, Dreadful) First 90 Days Of A New Job. Here's What To Expect

The Exciting (or, Dreadful) First 90 Days Of A New Job. Here's What To Expect

By: Isaiah Hankel, PhD

Like many PhDs, I thought I could jump into my first industry position ready to hit the ground running. Much to my surprise, this was not the case.   During the first few months of my new position, I felt like I was drowning. Everything I thought I knew about my field, how research is conducted, and how companies operate was turned on its head. I was not prepared for this major shift, and it showed. I waivered between trying to impress my managers and sitting mute in meetings, intimidated by everyone in the room. If I had known what…

5 Ways To Bomb A Perfectly Good Interview Presentation (And What Savvy PhDs Do Instead)

5 Ways To Bomb A Perfectly Good Interview Presentation (And What Savvy PhDs Do Instead)

By: Isaiah Hankel, PhD

The first time I was asked to give a presentation as part of an onsite interview, I thought, ‘Well this should be a cake walk – I’ll just redo my defense presentation.’ I didn’t get the job. And I knew that mid-way through my presentation. To start, they had only scheduled 30 minutes for my presentation, yet the one I had prepared was an hour. I ended up speed talking my way through the entire thing. Mistake number one. Mistake number two was not appealing to my audience. My presentation was highly technical, but my audience included people from R&D,…

Top Industry Career eBooks

Complete LinkedIn Guide For PhDs

Complete LinkedIn Guide For PhDs

Isaiah Hankel

The LinkedIn tips & strategies within have helped PhDs from every background get hired into top industry careers.

63 Best Industry Positions For PhDs

63 Best Industry Positions For PhDs

Isaiah Hankel, PhD & Arunodoy Sur, PhD

Learn about the best 63 industry careers for PhDs (regardless of your academic background). In this eBook, you will gain insight into the most popular, highest-paying jobs for PhDs – all of which will allow you to do meaningful work AND get paid well for it.

Industry Resume Guide for PhDs

Industry Resume Guide for PhDs

Isaiah Hankel, PhD

Learn how to craft the perfect industry resume to attract employers. In this eBook for PhDs, you will get access to proven resume templates, learn how to structure your bullet points, and discover which keywords industry employers want to see most on PhD resumes.