6 Colossal Interview Blunders That PhDs Routinely Make

When I started my industry job search, I thought interviews were merely a formality. Walking in the door, I was sure I already had the job.

But so many times, I walked into an interview full of confidence and walked out feeling hopeless and confused.

I was clearly botching my interviews, but I had no way of knowing where I was going wrong.

When I aired my frustration to a friend of mine in talent acquisition, she told me what hiring managers really care about. It was then that I realized my blunders.

It wasn’t that I was unqualified or not experienced enough. I wasn’t offered the job because of the way I acted in the interview itself.

Evidently, my body language was all wrong. I also failed to understand the importance of doing my research on the company ahead of time.

After making a few small tweaks to how I presented myself and how I answered questions, I started seeing results. I was finally getting job offers!

Another Cheeky Scientist member recently shared how their preparedness got them through a stressful interview situation:

“In one interview, I was hit with a ton of technical questions that I had not prepared for. But I had done my research on the company and their product.

After I received a job offer, the interviewer told me that my knowledge about the company is what set me apart from the other candidates. It was a really good to feel so prepared! It gave me the confidence under a pretty stressful situation.

Thank you Cheekies! I can hands-down say this was because of your teachings!”

In An Industry Interview, You Have Exactly 90 Seconds To Make A Good Impression

The average industry interview is 40 minutes long; however, a survey conducted by Undercover Recruiter found that one-third of recruiters know within the first 90 seconds whether they will recommend someone for a job.

Some studies have even found that hiring managers make up their mind in less than 10 seconds!

This means you have mere seconds to convince someone that you’re the best person for the job – so you better be well-prepared!

But what could possibly go so wrong in so little time?

There are many reasons recruiters and hiring managers reject a job candidate.

In fact, 67% of job candidates get rejected due to lack of eye contact; 55% because they had little or no knowledge of the company; 47% due to a lack of confidence or smile; and 33% because of bad posture or a weak handshake.

With so many companies struggling to find talent, there isn’t any reason why you – a highly-educated and highly-qualified individual – can’t get hired into industry.

6 Avoidable Interview Mistakes That Hold You Back From Your Ideal Industry Job (And What To Do Instead)

If you’ve been offered an industry interview, you should be ecstatic – filled with both anticipation and excitement…right?

But, if instead, you’re filled with dread and worry, think about why this is.

Are you nervous because you don’t know what questions they’ll ask? Are you losing sleep at night because you don’t feel like you’re qualified for the job?

At the heart of most interview dread is a lack of preparedness.

The good news is you can hone your interviewing skills and improve your preparedness through practice.

This starts with addressing your blunders.

Today, I’ll discuss 6 very avoidable blunders that PhDs make that keep them from landing their dream job in industry.

Blunder #1: Not understanding the hiring funnel.

Do you know what happens after you submit a job application? Probably not.

After hitting the send button, all you can do is wait.

But what’s happening behind the scenes? 

The ways by which companies find quality job candidates can vary considerably; however, what remains consistent, no matter the company, is the overall hiring and interview process.

A process better known as the hiring funnel.

There are four stages of the hiring funnel.

The first stage is resume acquisition. After posting an open position – whether it be on their website, LinkedIn, or another online portal – companies are inundated with resumes.

In fact, the average company receives over 500 resumes for every open position. And for corporate giants like Pfizer, Google, and Dow Chemical, this number can reach up to 2000.

For one single job!

Companies certainly aren’t going to interview hundreds – or thousands – of job applicants. So, to reduce the pool of candidates, companies employ a variety of screening methods.

Some use automated Applicant Tracking Systems (ATS), some have in-house talent acquisition teams, while others may outsource their hiring to recruiting companies.

No matter the method, what remains consistent is the number of applicants companies move forward with to the next stage of the hiring process: the phone interview.

Out of hundreds of applicants, only 12 to 15 candidates are invited for a phone screen. On a good day, that’s still less than 10% of the applicant pool!

So, if you get a phone interview you’ve already beaten substantial odds.

From there, the funnel narrows even more.

Once all remaining candidates have been through a phone screen, hiring managers then determine which candidates they want to invite for a video interview.

Typically, only 4 to 5 people make it to this stage. So again, if you’re called for a video interview, recognize that you’re one of only a handful of candidates to make it this far.  

Don’t take it for granted.

Also realize that companies frequently conduct several rounds of video interviews before finalizing their list of top candidates.

So you’re not off the hook after one video interview.

The final stage of the hiring funnel is typically the on-site visit. A standard on-site visit lasts the entire day and consists of numerous interviews – sometimes, upwards of 5 to 6.

Only 1 or 2 candidates are invited for an on-site visit. That’s because on-site interviews are expensive and time consuming.

If you get an on-site interview, a company is seriously considering you – don’t botch the opportunity.

To get hired in industry, you must see the hiring funnel from the employer’s point of view. The more you understand about the interview process, the more prepared you can be for those critical moments that catch so many PhDs off guard.

Blunder #2: Making a bad first impression

Like I mentioned earlier, the typical interview lasts around 40 minutes. But, the first 90 seconds of the interview are the most critical.

That’s because it only takes many hiring managers 90 seconds to determine if they are going to recommend you for the job.

This doesn’t seem fair – but fair or not, it’s something you should be aware of and be prepared for.

So, what can you do to impress your interviewer within the first few moments of your interview?

For one, make sure you dress appropriately and professionally. If your clothing is sloppy, disheveled, or too casual, it sends the message that you’re also sloppy, disheveled, and unprofessional in your work.

A firm handshake accompanied by a smile also goes a long way. Always ensure to make eye contact with the interviewer as well.

These may seem obvious, but you would be amazed at how many people fail their interview because they dressed poorly, didn’t make eye contact, or had a weak handshake.

You also want to show your potential employer that you’re confident. Avoid any body language that conveys self-doubt or nervousness such as crossing your arms, putting your hands in your pockets, touching your face, or fidgeting.

Within the first 90 seconds there’s only one or two questions that are frequently asked:

How are you today? And Can you tell me a little about yourself?

These seemingly innocuous questions open the lines of communication and can also tell the interviewer a lot about you as a person.

To answer the question ‘How are you?’, keep it simple. You can just say ‘Perfect!’ or ‘I’m perfect, thank you. How are you?’.

For the question ‘Can you tell me a little about yourself?’, you should always use your elevator pitch. Many PhDs make the mistake of rambling on because they don’t know how to answer such an open-ended question.

So, come prepared with a concise 5- to 10-second-long pitch about who you are. It is sure to impress your interviewers.

Overall, first impressions are everything – appropriate attire, a good handshake, voice, tonality and positive body language will set you up for success.

Blunder #3: Not preparing an elevator pitch

Many PhDs tend to overthink their response when asked to share something about themselves. A million thoughts enter their mind.

Where do I start? Do they want to know about me professionally? Should I say anything about me personally?

To avoid rambling on about your love of French cooking or providing your life story, prepare an elevator pitch and perfect it through practice – convey who you are and why they should care.

Share something about you professionally. Provide a touch of humanity by also describing something about you personally – like a hobby or an interest.  

You should also demonstrate your interest in the role and describe what your ultimate goals are. It should be about something outside or larger than yourself.

For example, you could say: I’m an immunologist and I love camping on the weekends. I want to be a project manager (or whatever the role is) because I’d really like to see my scientific knowledge translated into products that help people.

Write out your elevator pitch and practice it out loud. Over time, it will become second nature.

Master this and you’ll not only leave a good first impression, but you’ll set up the rest of your interview for success.

Blunder #4: Not doing the homework.

Another all-too-common reason many people, PhDs included, fail an interview is because they don’t know anything about the company.

During an interview, many employers will ask some version of ‘What do you know about our company?’

If you walk into an interview having no clue about what the company does, the job description, or your reasons for applying (other than you need a job), then you haven’t done your homework.

Before an interview, find out everything you can about the company. Identify their mission, their values, and their goals. Learn about any recent mergers or acquisitions.

This information not only helps you answer questions pertaining to the company, but it also helps you determine if a company is a good cultural fit for you.

Maintaining a good company culture is vital to the success of a business, therefore, it’s critical they hire the right people.

That means companies will be vetting you – your goals and your values – throughout the interview process to ensure it’s a good match.

If you can show that you’re knowledgeable about the company, understand what’s important to them, and can describe how you’ll provide further value to their mission, then you’re bound to leave a good impression.

Blunder #5: Neglecting the STAR method

Before an interview, there is only so much you can prepare. That’s because there’s no way of knowing what kind of questions you’ll be asked.

Like the Cheeky Scientist member above, you can prepare to answer all the standard behavioral questions, only to be thrown a curve ball – one that includes a long list of highly technical questions.

But, like this Cheeky member, if you have a solid understanding of the company along with a standard method of answering tough questions, you will stand out amongst the applicants.

One of the most tried and true methods for answering interview questions is the STAR method.

STAR stands for situation, task, action, and results.

When asked a question, you want to set up your answer in this order. Start by describing a previous work situation that pertains to the question.

Then, talk about what you were tasked with in this particular situation along with the specific actions you took.

And lastly, discuss the end result. When doing so, it’s best to mention quantifiable results – money obtained, number of projects completed, etc.

For example: ‘In my current role as a project manager , I am responsible for managing 3 cutting-edge early-concept projects where I lead a team of 30 people, ensuring that deadlines are met and quality is retained. As a result, my company recently received a $500,000 innovation grant based on their contribution to the field of cancer research’.

No matter what question is thrown at you, you can effectively answer by using this format and ensuring to emphasize not just your technical know-how but also your transferable skills.

Blunder #6: Disengaging and not asking questions

I get it – interviews are exhausting. Especially if they’re an all-day event.

But the fastest way to land yourself on the rejection list is to disengage and/or fail to show interest during an interview.

People feed off your energy. If you’re upbeat, enthusiastic, and genuinely happy to be there, the interviewer will likely reciprocate these feelings.

They then, in turn, will be enthusiastic about you.

So, during your interview, remain engaged. Smile, nod when they speak, ensure to face towards them at all times and maintain eye contact (in a not-so-creepy way).

Also, make sure you’re asking questions of them. This redirects the focus towards them and gives you a moment to breath while showing them your interest in the company.

It’s also the best way to learn more about the company and the role.

Ask about their current role, how they got there, what the culture at the company is like, how teams are structured – and the list goes on.

An interview is not just a way of assessing your skills – it’s also to see what it’s like to work alongside you.

If you’re disengaged, uninterested, and have one foot out the door the whole interview, no one will want to work with you.

Concluding Remarks

Interviewing is tough. I don’t know anyone that enjoys it. But interviewing well is the only way to land your ideal job in industry. An effective interview starts with a great first impression. Oftentimes, your fate is decided within the first few seconds of the interview. You have to put your best foot forward. So, make sure you dress and carry yourself professionally. Ensure to remain engaged, open, and enthusiastic. You also have to come prepared. Perfect your elevator pitch and practice the STAR method until all of it becomes second nature. Interviewing is not a talent; it’s a skill. One that can be mastered and result in a long and successful career in industry.

If you’re ready to start your transition into industry, you can apply to book a free Transition Call with our founder Isaiah Hankel, PhD or one of our Transition Specialists. Apply to book a Transition Call here.

Book a Transition Call
Get Free Job Search Content Weekly

ABOUT ISAIAH HANKEL, PHD

CEO, CHEEKY SCIENTIST & SUCCESS MENTOR TO PHDS

Isaiah Hankel, PhD is the Founder and CEO of the largest career training platform for PhDs in the world - Cheeky Scientist. His articles, podcasts and trainings are consumed annually by 3 million PhDs in 152 different countries. He has helped PhDs transition into top companies like Amazon, Google, Apple, Intel, DOW Chemical, BASF, Merck, Genentech, Home Depot, Nestle, Hilton, SpaceX, Tesla, Syngenta, the CDC, UN and Ford Foundation.

Dr. Isaiah Hankel received his doctorate in Anatomy & Cell Biology with a focus in immunology and is an expert on biotechnology recruitment and career development.

Isaiah has published two bestselling books with Wiley and his methods for getting PhDs hired have been featured in the Harvard Business Review, Nature, Forbes, The Guardian, Fast Company, Entrepreneur Magazine and Success Magazine.

Isaiah About Photo

Similar Articles

Is Your Body Language Costing You The Job?

Is Your Body Language Costing You The Job?

By: Isaiah Hankel, PhD

I ran into an old colleague a few days ago – literally. We actually collided going into the same coffee shop.  As luck would have it, we both had some time to kill, so we took a seat and started visiting. I told him all about the work I do, connecting PhDs with the strategies to get hired in industry.  He’d since gone on to work in human resources as a manager at one of the Global 500. We talked about things we wish we’d known after graduation – the importance of things like networking and creating a powerful resume…

5 Ways To Bomb A Perfectly Good Interview Presentation (And What Savvy PhDs Do Instead)

5 Ways To Bomb A Perfectly Good Interview Presentation (And What Savvy PhDs Do Instead)

By: Isaiah Hankel, PhD

The first time I was asked to give a presentation as part of an onsite interview, I thought, ‘Well this should be a cake walk – I’ll just redo my defense presentation.’ I didn’t get the job. And I knew that mid-way through my presentation. To start, they had only scheduled 30 minutes for my presentation, yet the one I had prepared was an hour. I ended up speed talking my way through the entire thing. Mistake number one. Mistake number two was not appealing to my audience. My presentation was highly technical, but my audience included people from R&D,…

The PhD Cheat Sheet For Conquering An Onsite Interview

The PhD Cheat Sheet For Conquering An Onsite Interview

By: Isaiah Hankel, PhD

When I was offered my first onsite interview, I was elated. But that elation quickly turned into panic. I had no idea what to expect. I had heard about other colleague’s interviewing experiences, but they all seemed so different. Some were in panel interviews, some had back-to-back one-on-one interviews, others had presentations, while others had a combination of all the above. I didn’t even know where to start in my preparation. So, I did what many PhDs do. I memorized verbatim answers to a handful of interview questions. I even reread my thesis to make sure I remembered every last…

The Shrewd PhD's Guide For Answering Behavioral Interview Questions

The Shrewd PhD's Guide For Answering Behavioral Interview Questions

By: Isaiah Hankel, PhD

I went through three rounds of interviews and now the company is ghosting me! What did I do wrong?! I’ve heard so many PhDs utter these words. If you can relate, chances are, you’re not going into your later stage interviews fully prepared. You may think that you’re in the clear or that late-stage interviews don’t matter as much. No matter the reason, just know that now is not the time to put your guard down.   The key to nailing later stage interviews is anticipation and preparation.   You must anticipate what types of questions you’ll get during an…

6 Ways To Crush The Competition During Your Next  Video Interview

6 Ways To Crush The Competition During Your Next Video Interview

By: Isaiah Hankel, PhD

During my first industry job search, I was doing everything I could to prepare for in-person interviews. I got together with friends and colleagues, asked them to act as the interviewer and give me the tough questions. I asked them to critique my body language, my speech, and even how I planned to dress.   I really thought I was ready. So, after my first successful phone screen, I was completely sidelined when they told me the next steps included a video interview. A video interview? I wasn’t ready for this! At first, I prepared for it as I would…

Don't Flub The Phone Screen (8 Expert Tips For PhDs)

Don't Flub The Phone Screen (8 Expert Tips For PhDs)

By: Isaiah Hankel, PhD

I don’t think I’m alone when I say I dread phone calls. I’m willing to spend hours online trying to fix a problem just to avoid the 5-to-10-minute phone conversation it would require to solve it.    If this sounds familiar, I have some bad news: phone calls are unavoidable during your industry job search. In fact, its common for the first interaction between a job candidate and an employer to take place over the phone. This is called the phone screen. When I started my industry job search, I had no idea that phone screens were part of the…

Master The Informational Interview (And How To Land A Referral)

Master The Informational Interview (And How To Land A Referral)

By: Isaiah Hankel, PhD

By the time I started my industry job search, I was desperate. I was nearing the end of my PhD and I was consumed with what seemed like a million last-minute tasks – final experiments, last drafts, and defense presentations. I felt like I didn’t have the time to dedicate to my job search. And what little effort and time I did put into it was haphazard. My attempts involved repeatedly clicking the LinkedIn “Connect” button and uploading the same resume to any online job posting I could find. To make matters worse, I wasn’t even sure what job I…

5 Job Search Time Wasters That PhDs Should Stop Doing Immediately

5 Job Search Time Wasters That PhDs Should Stop Doing Immediately

By: Isaiah Hankel, PhD

Feeling discouraged with your job search strategy? Have you uploaded hundreds of resumes without hearing back from employers? Are you starting to think you are not cut out for an industry position? This happens to many PhDs at some point in their transition journey.  They don’t know how to execute a correct job search strategy. So they waste lots of time doing things that don’t yield any result. Then get discouraged. An industry job search is maddening. As PhDs we are never trained rigorously on how to do it in academia. Most PhDs are never trained on how to execute…

The Number One Reason PhDs Fail To Get Hired In Industry

The Number One Reason PhDs Fail To Get Hired In Industry

By: Isaiah Hankel, PhD

Today, I want to talk about the number one reason you are not being hired. You might think it’s because you are overqualified or underqualified for your target position. Or that you just can’t get hired because you lack industry experience. But the number one reason you are not getting hired is because you are invisible to industry hiring managers and recruiters. They simply don’t know who you are or the value you bring to the table. Understanding and accepting this should encourage you to change the way that you approach your job search.  Only then will you increase your…

Top Industry Career eBooks

Complete LinkedIn Guide For PhDs

Complete LinkedIn Guide For PhDs

Isaiah Hankel

The LinkedIn tips & strategies within have helped PhDs from every background get hired into top industry careers.

63 Best Industry Positions For PhDs

63 Best Industry Positions For PhDs

Isaiah Hankel, PhD & Arunodoy Sur, PhD

Learn about the best 63 industry careers for PhDs (regardless of your academic background). In this eBook, you will gain insight into the most popular, highest-paying jobs for PhDs – all of which will allow you to do meaningful work AND get paid well for it.

Industry Resume Guide for PhDs

Industry Resume Guide for PhDs

Isaiah Hankel, PhD

Learn how to craft the perfect industry resume to attract employers. In this eBook for PhDs, you will get access to proven resume templates, learn how to structure your bullet points, and discover which keywords industry employers want to see most on PhD resumes.