How PhDs Can Use Job Boards, Internal Referrals, And Recruiters To Get Industry Jobs

If you asked me during my PhD where to apply for a postdoc, I could have named at least a dozen research groups.

I knew all the reputable experts in my field and was almost certain they would accept me as a postdoc ― or at least point me in the direction of a collaborator.

I knew the best options for seeking funding, deadlines for applications, and how to write a compelling research proposal.

It would have been an easy transition.

If I was honest with myself, however, I knew I would just be buying time and delaying my eventual career move outside of my bubble in academia.

When I looked to see what the job market had to offer, I realized how little I knew.

The last time I looked for a non-academic job was when I was in high school.

High school was a long time ago and this time I wasn’t looking to serve fries.

Where do people find jobs nowadays?

I felt out-of-date and out-of-touch.

I had no network outside of academia to tap into to find these resources.

I aimlessly began to search online.

I Googled ‘jobs for PhDs’.

Seemed simple enough.

Except that rather than job listings, I was bombarded by skepticism.

I read articles about how big name employers would see me as a career-changer, with no more work experience than a first degree graduate.

As a PhD, I was relegated to a bottom rung employee.

This was as appealing to me as flipping burgers and serving fries.

In fact, being older and more specialized than first degree graduates would actually put me at a disadvantage.

Are you kidding me?

I needed to take a step back and develop a strategy.

I needed to find the best sources for job opportunities for PhDs and prioritize.

If I put in just half the amount of effort I spent writing my thesis to obtaining a non-academic job, there was nothing that could stop me.

Once I developed the right mindset and found the right sources, everything began to fall in line.

I needed to start networking, gaining referrals, and marketing myself as an employable, experienced, job candidate.

Why Doing A Postdoc Is A Default Option

A recent study reported in Science found that more than three-quarters of life science students believed they needed to do at least a year of postdoc research in order to qualify for an industry position.

This is absolutely wrong.

But the idea that you need to do a postdoc is so prevalent that it’s now known as the postdoc default trap.

Or, the permadoc trap.

Either way ― it’s a lie.

You do not need to do a postdoc to get an industry job.

Yet, many PhDs still believe they have to join the ‘holding pattern’ of doing a postdoc until an industry job becomes available.

As a result, each and every year, a line of frustrated PhDs stream into this funnel like cattle.

The reality is that your time is better spent executing a proper job search.

Instead of doing a postdoc, aim to get into an industry job right away by seeking out the best job search sources.

Of equal importance is knowing to diversify your job search.

Your skills are not confined to your specialized PhD project.

You have the skills to go into many diverse alternative career paths.

Knowing this will automatically expand your job search.

Create a list of technical and transferable skills that you could impart to a new company and that you would find fulfilling to develop.

Once you broaden your scope, you can start to amass leads and market yourself accordingly.

3 Top Sources For Finding An Industry Job

When PhDs search for new jobs, one of the most important elements is developing leads.

How do you uncover the largest number of job leads and do so consistently?

The answer is to leverage multiple sources.  

There are many methods to choose from and, at the end of the day, while some may produce a high quantity of jobs leads, it may come at the cost of quality.

As time and resources permit, use as many of these methods as possible to generate high quality job sources.

But to be successful, you need to follow up on EVERY job lead.

Your goal should be to turn every lead into a job referral, and eventually a job interview.

For example, once you submit your cover letter and industry resume, follow up a short time later to ensure it was received and ask for more information.

It is useless to invest time in developing job leads and missing out by not aggressively following up.

The key is to be professional and not overbearing but be persistent.

Stay organized by keeping a log to track each job, the dates you followed up, who you followed up with, and the next time you follow up.

Remember, you must leverage multiple sources to get as many leads as possible and then work to turn these leads into referrals and eventually interviews.

When it comes to developing leads, you should leverage these three top sources…

1. Online job sites and job boards.

This is by far the most popular way to search for jobs due to the wealth of job listings at your fingertips.

But it’s one of the most ineffective ways of actually getting a job.

These sites provide quantity, but lack in quality.

Still, you can learn a lot by trolling job sites.

You can also build relationships by leveraging the contact information on these sites.

A recent report by business analyst, Jeremy Marsan showed that job boards ― such as Indeed.com ― receive 2 million new resumes in their database every month.

LinkedIn, on the other hand, has over 414 million profiles.

There are connections to be made, but you have to actively reach out to create these connections.

Job sites can be categorized from general to specific.

Job search engines ― including Indeed and SimplyHired ― pull job postings from many different sites including job boards, online classified advertisements, and employer websites.

Job Boards include: Careerbuilder, Monster, Linkedin, and Glassdoor.

Companies pay money to post jobs on these platforms.

There are also industry-specific websites such as Nature Jobs and AAAS for scientists and geographic-specific job sites such as TorontoJobs or Bostonjobs.

Setting up targeted searches on these job sites can give you an idea of not only current jobs, but also which organizations might be recruiting PhDs in your discipline for future roles.

You should use these sites as sources to gain an understanding of each employer you might be interested in working for.

Once you have found relevant employers, go to their company websites and set up alerts for upcoming job openings.

For all of these sites, you have the opportunity to set up your own profile as well.

But don’t expect to receive emails or phone calls from hiring managers simply by setting up a completed profile.  

You will still have to do the leg work of applying and reaching out to hiring managers and recruiters to ensure your application is at the top of their list.

2. Networking and internal referrals.

This is, hands down, the MOST effective way to find an industry job.

If you have not learned the power of networking already, you are sorely missing out on the majority of job leads.

As your network grows, so will the number of potential sources to learn about new jobs.

Networking takes time and energy.

You must get focused on where your time and energy is going.

Stop spending all your time perfecting your resume, and invest time where it counts your network.

Be organized and set up a database to enter key information about the people in your network.

Communicate with them on a regular basis.

Start easy ― friends, family, neighbors, and former colleagues.

Ask them for advice or for introductions to quickly expand your network.

Set up informational interviews to gain insider information about different companies and fields while building your network simultaneously.

If you have never networked outside of academia before, start looking for events to attend.

Use Meetups or Eventbrite as an online source.

Networking events can be related to the industry you are looking for or can be social events completely unrelated to your job search.

These events can be hidden gems for making connections with people that may share valuable leads with you in the future.

Use social media ― such as LinkedIn and even Twitter ― to increase awareness of your professional profile, and engage in online discussions with like-minded people.

But…

Do NOT ask for referrals immediately.  

The key to networking is cultivating these relationships so, when a job opens, you are the first person that springs to mind as the most qualified candidate.

You want to be in a position where asking for a referral is easy.

Where the other person doesn’t see it as an imposition because they know enough about you to trust you.

Consistency builds trust.

Add value consistently and you’ll be in a great position to ask for a referral.

There’s another reason why networking and internal referrals are so important…

Networking unlocks a hidden job market where positions that are never advertised online can become available to you because you’ve made a connection with a hiring manager or employee.

Also, current employees at your company of interest WANT to get you hired.

They want to get you hired because industry companies provide referral incentives.

In other words, when an employee refers you and you get hired, the employee gets a monetary reward or “bonus” from the company.

3. Recruiters and headhunters.

Recruiters or headhunters can be good sources for obtaining job leads.

PhD students are not typical candidates for recruiters, but you should not rule them out entirely when executing your job search.

The most important thing to remember about recruiters is that they are working for money.

As a result, they will likely NOT have your best interests as their top priority.

But this is okay.

As long as you know where you stand with recruiters, you can leverage them to gain insights about a company.

You can leverage them to get multiple job offers too.

Recruitment firms can be divided into two groups: retained or contingency.

A retained recruiter means they will charge an upfront fee to the client (company) to conduct a search.

They will operate on an exclusive basis, meaning that the job will only be filled through this recruitment company.

The process is rigorous, with a shortlist of a few names being presented before interviews begin.

Contingency recruiters are only paid when a candidate takes the position with their client.

They have to compete with the client’s internal HR department, advertising, direct applications and perhaps other recruitment companies to find the right hire.

They need to find the best candidate, and find them faster than everyone else.  

As the job candidate, you can ask how the recruiter obtained the assignment for the position of interest and what the competition is.

A retained recruiter may have more information about the role, interviews, a potential offer, etc. while the contingency recruiter may be more pro-active and have a greater sense of urgency to get you hired.

Either way, a professional and completed LinkedIn profile is a great way to get recruiters to find you, and to reach out to recruiters.

You can also find directories of recruiters by geographical area or discipline online.

Regardless of the source, diversifying your job search will help you transition out of academia faster. The most reliable ― and smartest ― source is through networking and working to get internal referrals. Putting in the extra effort to build your network will allow you access to jobs that are not advertised online, drastically reducing the size of the competition. Networking toward a referral is hard work and you need to be organized. Keep a log of all your contacts and when you were last in touch, jobs you’ve applied for, and your follow-up attempts. Persistence is key and will show your future employer that you are the most motivated for the position.

To learn more about transitioning into industry, including instant access to our exclusive training videos, case studies, industry insider documents, transition plan, and private online network, get on the wait list for the Cheeky Scientist Association.

Join Cheeky Scientist Association
Get Free Job Search Content Weekly
Catherine Sorbara, Ph.D.
Catherine Sorbara, Ph.D.

Cathy has a PhD in Medical Life Science and Technology and is COO of the Cheeky Scientist Association. Cathy is passionate about science communication including translating science to lay audiences and helping PhDs transition into industry positions. She is Chair of Cambridge AWiSE, a regional network for women in science, engineering and technology. She has also been selected to take part in Homeward Bound 2018, an all-female voyage to Antarctica aimed to heighten the influence of women in leadership positions and bring awareness to climate change.

Similar Articles

Intelligent, Powerful Salary Negotiations For PhDs In 5 Simple Steps

Intelligent, Powerful Salary Negotiations For PhDs In 5 Simple Steps

By: Sarah Smith, PhD

Contributing Author: Marios Tsatsos, PhD After my interview, I got a call from the HR department. This was the big phone call – the one about money. I had interviewed well, and the person from HR was calling to let me know he was about to meet with the hiring manager. Hopefully, he said, there would be an offer for me after they met. It was time for the negotiation.  Then he asked about salary…  I didn’t want to give the first number, so I deflected his question with a joke. It worked, and the representative mentioned the first salary…

Recessions Are Tough - 3 Ways PhDs Can Be Tougher

Recessions Are Tough - 3 Ways PhDs Can Be Tougher

By: Isaiah Hankel, PhD

Let’s talk about frustration.  I’m talking about the frustration of a rejection in your job search.  Many PhDs are experiencing this kind of frustration in their post-pandemic job search. It’s important for you to understand that Cheeky Scientist has been through this before.  Cheeky Scientist actually came out of the financial crash of 2008 when we were in a recession.  I can tell you firsthand that the mood of the public changes during a recession.  There are fewer jobs.  There’s a greater sense of urgency.  This causes people to get more rejections. And rejection leads to frustration.  So, how can…

5 Smart Moves PhDs Can Make At A Networking Event

5 Smart Moves PhDs Can Make At A Networking Event

By: Sarah Smith, PhD

LinkedIn is an excellent resource for networking, and it makes the whole process easier than ever before. But LinkedIn should not be the only place you are meeting industry professionals. You need to attend in-person networking events too. Meeting in person allows someone to get to know you at a far more significant level than the internet alone will allow. The amount of rapport and relationship-building that can occur during a 10-minute, in-person interaction could take months if attempted over the internet. There is no substitute for face-to-face networking – it’s what we as a species have evolved to do.…

Follow These 5 Resume Rules For A Successful Job Search

Follow These 5 Resume Rules For A Successful Job Search

By: Aditya Sharma, PhD

Are you submitting your resume to online job postings? You might be surprised to learn that your resume is never even seen by a human being. 98% of Fortune 500 companies use applicant tracking software, according to Jobscan. Large-size firms (those that employ more than 500 individuals) receive many thousands of resumes every week. The only way their hiring departments can be functional is by using tracking software to weed out unqualified candidates. This puts applicants in kind of a tough spot - optimize your resume to get through the tracking software or get used to rejection. Even highly qualified…

3 Secrets To Networking That Don’t Involve Meeting People

3 Secrets To Networking That Don’t Involve Meeting People

By: Aditya Sharma, PhD

If you underestimate the power of networking, you’re going to make things really hard for yourself. Are you exclusively relying on applications and resumes? If you are, that’s called putting all your eggs in one basket. Don’t do that. Lou Adler, CEO of Performance-Based Hiring Learning Systems, reports that 85% of jobs are filled by networking. This isn’t surprising when you consider that networking is the only way to get referrals. According to Undercover Recruiter, only 7% of job applicants get referrals — but those who do get referrals account for 40% of those who get hired. By the time…

5 Common Phrases PhDs Say That Will Ruin Informational Interviews

5 Common Phrases PhDs Say That Will Ruin Informational Interviews

By: Jeanette McConnell, PhD

You know that you need to network. You’ve heard of informational interviews and want to try them out. But what if you say the wrong thing? What if you put in all this time meeting someone, talking to them, following up with them and the connection leads to nothing? Here are 5 things that you should not say while networking at an informational interview.

Get Hired Without Submitting a Resume - 5 Networking Strategies For PhDs

Get Hired Without Submitting a Resume - 5 Networking Strategies For PhDs

By: Surayya Taranum

Networking is the only foolproof method for PhDs wanting to transition into an industry career. Learn the 5 effective networking strategies that give you an edge in the job market.

How I Got Hired Right After I Had A Baby - Tips For PhDs Job Search Strategy As A New Parent

How I Got Hired Right After I Had A Baby - Tips For PhDs Job Search Strategy As A New Parent

By: Mansi Khanna, PhD

The ideal time to start focusing on your job search is now. No matter if you have just started your PhD or if you are unemployed and want a job ASAP, the best thing you can do it start now. Balance Careers reported that roughly it takes one month to find a job for every $10,000 of the paycheck you would like to earn. So, as a PhD if you want to earn $90,000 per year, your job search could take about 9 months. BUT this is an estimate. Depending on the effort your put in and any networking efforts…

Use This 5-Part Job Search Strategy To Get Multiple Industry Job Interviews And Job Offers As A PhD

Use This 5-Part Job Search Strategy To Get Multiple Industry Job Interviews And Job Offers As A PhD

By: Pierre-Antoine Crassous, PhD

No one is coming to knock on the door of your lab and offer you a job. Getting a job requires strategy. Large companies, like Google, Microsoft, Pfizer, etc get 1,000s of applications per job opening. If you are relying on luck to make you the 1:1,000 that gets hired, you are going to be waiting a long time. Instead, you should be strategic. Realize that, according to JobScan, 98% of Fortune 500 companies use applicant tracking software to screen resumes. And understand that employers care more about your soft skills than they do about your specific technical skills. Inside…

Top Industry Career eBooks

Complete LinkedIn Guide For PhDs

Complete LinkedIn Guide For PhDs

Isaiah Hankel

The LinkedIn tips & strategies within have helped PhDs from every background get hired into top industry careers.

20 Most Popular Industry Career Tracks For PhDs

20 Most Popular Industry Career Tracks For PhDs

Isaiah Hankel, PhD & Arunodoy Sur, PhD

Learn about the top 20 industry careers for PhDs (regardless of your academic background). In this eBook, you will gain insight into the most popular, highest-paying jobs for PhDs – all of which will allow you to do meaningful work AND get paid well for it.

Industry Resume Guide for PhDs

Industry Resume Guide for PhDs

Isaiah Hankel, PhD

Learn how to craft the perfect industry resume to attract employers. In this eBook for PhDs, you will get access to proven resume templates, learn how to structure your bullet points, and discover which keywords industry employers want to see most on PhD resumes.