The Shrewd PhD’s Guide For Answering Behavioral Interview Questions

I went through three rounds of interviews and now the company is ghosting me! What did I do wrong?!

I’ve heard so many PhDs utter these words.

If you can relate, chances are, you’re not going into your later stage interviews fully prepared.

You may think that you’re in the clear or that late-stage interviews don’t matter as much. No matter the reason, just know that now is not the time to put your guard down.  

The key to nailing later stage interviews is anticipation and preparation.  

You must anticipate what types of questions you’ll get during an interview. You also must perfect your method of answering questions and go in prepared with questions of your own.

As one Cheeky Scientist recounts:

‘I had a second-round interview last week. Most of the questions they asked were behavioral in nature.

These are all quite common as I have been asked similar questions in the past.

Thanks to Cheeky, I anticipated that I would get questions along these lines, and so I prepared before my interview. I learned today that I am proceeding to the next round!’

How To Be Remarkable To Employers During Late-Stage Interviews

If you’ve spent any time on the job market, you know how grueling the interview process can be.

Most companies put job candidates through phone screens, several video interviews, and sometimes multiple rounds of in-person interviews.

That’s because with an average per hire cost of $4,700, hiring is expensive.

And the overall cost of hiring an employee goes far beyond the cost of interviewing – it also includes onboarding, training, and so much more.

In fact, between 2020 and 2021, companies spent $92 billion on training new hires.  

With this price tag, employers want to make sure they’re hiring the best candidates.

That’s why, on average, employers conduct 2-3 rounds of interviews with a candidate before choosing who they’re going to hire.

And if you’re doing your job search right, you’re going through this process with several companies at the same.

That means you’re doing a whole lot of interviewing. But as exhausting as it might be, you can’t take any step of the process for granted.

Especially your late-stage interviews.

At this stage, many PhDs mistakenly think that all the hard work is behind them and they can start to relax.

This just isn’t true.

You may have fewer candidates to compete with, but that doesn’t mean that the competition has dissipated.

You still have to prove that, out of a handful of candidates, you are the best person for the job.  

And, as I said before, the key to nailing your late-stage interviews is anticipation and preparation.

So today, I’m going to guide you through 3 tips that will be sure to impress your interviewers at all stages of the interviewing process.

3 Pro Tips For Answering PhD-Level Interview Questions

1. Know the 4 types of interview questions.

There are 4 categories of questions that you can expect in an interview: credibility, opinion-based, competency, and behavioral.

Credibility questions are typically the first type of question you’ll receive. They’re asked to get the job candidate talking. And just as the name suggests, they’re used to test your credibility.

These are questions that pertain to your resume. While they’ve already reviewed your resume prior to the interview, they want to hear from you regarding your work history and experience.

Some examples of credibility questions include: ‘Can you tell me a little about yourself?’, ‘How long did you work at company XYZ?’, and ‘Can you explain your responsibilities at company XYZ?’

It’s important that your answers remain consistent with what is written on your resume. That’s the credibility part.

You also want to ensure you have a well-practiced elevator pitch at the ready for the open-ended question ‘Can you tell me a little about yourself?’.  

Next, prepare to be asked a few opinion-based questions.

Opinion-based questions are asked to gauge your ability to fit into their company culture. They’re also used to assess your transferable skills.

Some examples of opinion-based questions include: ‘What do you think are your greatest strengths and weaknesses?’, ‘What type of leader do you prefer to work for?’, and ‘What would you do if faced with this type of situation?’

Ultimately, these types of questions are used to better understand how you view yourself as an employee and where you see yourself fitting in.

The next, and perhaps most dreaded, type of question you’ll get in an interview is behavioral. These are particularly popular for high paying jobs.

Company’s employ behavioral questions to see how you respond under stress – your reactions to high pressure situations.

There are two types of behavioral questions to look out for – negatively positioned and positively positioned ones.

Negatively positioned ones include questions like: ‘What do you do when you disagree with a client?’, ‘Tell me about a mistake you made at work and how you resolved it’, and ‘How do you handle a difficult situation with a supervisor?’

Negative questions are posed to see if you’re someone that is quick to shift blame.

They want to know, are you going to claim responsibility for your faults and mistakes, work with others to resolve issues, and improve yourself in areas of weakness?

Some examples of positively positioned questions include: ‘Can you describe a situation where you were able to persuade someone to see things your way?’, ‘When have you used good judgment and logic to solve a problem?’, and ‘What goals have you set for your self in the past year and how did you achieve them?

Positive questions offer you an opportunity to speak to your strengths and abilities. Don’t shy away from it.

Claim full ownership of your successes and accomplishments.

The last type of question you can expect is the competency question. The goal of these questions is straightforward – they want to know if you have the required skills for the job.

Some examples of competency questions include: ‘Can you tell me a time you used XYZ skill?’, ‘Can you give me an example of when you did XYZ?’, and ‘Can you think of a time you were stuck in your research? If so, how did you overcome it?’

Overall, interview questions are used to assess three major things: your critical thinking, judgement and decision-making, and your problem-solving skills.

You want to prove yourself capable in all three areas. So, keep these in mind when answering questions.

2. Master the STAR method of answering interview questions.  

When preparing for an interview, many PhDs make the mistake of memorizing their answers to specific interview questions.

The problem is you can’t possibly anticipate all the questions that you’ll be asked. Simply memorizing your answers will also come across as robotic and awkward.

Instead, prepare for interviews by practicing a method for answering questions rather than practicing responses verbatim.

The most tried and true method for answering interview questions is the STAR method. STAR stands for situation, task, action, and result.

To start, you have to set the scene. Employers don’t just want to know what your experience is – they also want to know where you acquired it. This is the situation.

Next, describe the task. Explain the goal you were trying to accomplish or a problem that you encountered.

Then, lay out how you addressed the problem or accomplished the goal. This is the action. This part of STAR is critical – it provides employers a glimpse of how you’ll act on the job.

This is the time to show that you are an effective problem-solver, and not someone to shy away from a challenge.

And lastly, explain the results of your actions. What was the outcome and how did you get there? Think of this as your punchline. It should be clear and powerful.

Employers want to know that you can achieve results that are important to industry.

Let’s say you were asked, ‘What is the biggest challenge you’ve faced, and how did you overcome it?’.

To answer, you could say ‘In my second year of grad school, I began working on a collaborative project that hadn’t made much headway. To move the project forward, I set up a weekly check-in where everyone involved shared updates, resolved issues, and set future timelines. As a result, we were able to identify some of the pain-points which, in the end, resulted in the completion of the project. Not only that, but we also came in 10% below budget.’

When answering, keep in mind that it’s not the time to portray yourself as an unflawed superhero. This will only make you sound phony.

Sharing an honest problem that you’ve encountered will create rapport with employers and increase your credibility.

Overall, the STAR method helps highlight your skills in a way that’s relatable. Practice it, apply it in your interviews, and you’ll be sure to make a lasting impression.

3. Ask potential employers impactful questions.

During an interview, you will likely be asked if you have any questions for them – usually towards the end of the interview.

This is your time to clarify the job description and get a better understanding of how the company operates.

It’s also their time to assess your level of interest and how well you understand the job and/or the company. In a way, it’s another competency question.

A few examples of structural questions you could ask include: ‘In this role, who will I be reporting to? Who will be reporting to me?’, ‘How are things organized within the company?’, and ‘Has the company undergone any recent mergers or acquisitions?’

It’s also good to ask future facing questions like: ‘What emerging markets is the company getting into?’, and ‘What are the corporate goals for the next year?’

This shows that you’re interested in the future success of the company.

It’s also good to ask about the career trajectory of someone in the position. This is not only invaluable information, but it also signals that you’re serious about the job – that you’re in it for the long haul.

Moreover, asking questions in a way that places the company in a good light always creates a positive impact. You just want to be careful not to sound like you’re trying to kiss up to them.

For example, you could ask: ‘I read the overall growth of the company has doubled in the last five years, making this an opportune time to join the company. In your opinion, how has R&D been affected by this growth?’

This shows that you’ve done your research on the company, that you recognize their accomplishments, and that you understand that this can result in some growing pains.

Overall, ask insightful questions that show employers that you understand how industry operates – that you know what is most valuable to the company.

You also want to show them that you are thinking in terms of the future and a long-term career with them.  

Concluding Remarks

The interview process is exhausting. For every job you interview for, you can expect to speak to someone at the company at least 3 times before they make a decision. And while this is both exhausting and time consuming, you shouldn’t take any stage of the interview process for granted. To land your ideal job in industry, you must impress employers at every step along the way. Especially during your late-stage interviews. To prepare, you should anticipate the types of questions you will be asked. Each interview is unique, but there are 4 major types of questions you can expect to receive during an interview. Learn these. You must also hone your responses using the STAR method. Memorizing your responses to standard questions won’t do the trick. And lastly, you should go into your interview equipped with insightful well-researched questions of your own. Overall, a solid foundation in interview Q & A will guarantee you stand heads and shoulders above the competition.  

If you’re ready to start your transition into industry, you can apply to book a free Transition Call with our founder Isaiah Hankel, PhD or one of our Transition Specialists. Apply to book a Transition Call here.

Book a Transition Call
Get Free Job Search Content Weekly
Isaiah Hankel, PhD
Isaiah Hankel, PhD Chief Executive Officer at Cheeky Scientist

Dr. Isaiah Hankel is the Founder and CEO of the largest career training platform for PhDs in the world - Cheeky Scientist. His articles, podcasts and trainings are consumed annually by 3 million PhDs in 152 different countries. He has helped PhDs transition into top companies like Amazon, Google, Apple, Intel, Dow Chemical, BASF, Merck, Genentech, Home Depot, Nestle, Hilton, SpaceX, Tesla, Syngenta, the CDC, UN and Ford Foundation.

Dr. Hankel has published two bestselling books with Wiley and his methods for getting PhDs hired have been featured in the Harvard Business Review, Nature, Forbes, The Guardian, Fast Company, Entrepreneur Magazine and Success Magazine.

Similar Articles

5 Ways To Bomb A Perfectly Good Interview Presentation (And What Savvy PhDs Do Instead)

5 Ways To Bomb A Perfectly Good Interview Presentation (And What Savvy PhDs Do Instead)

By: Isaiah Hankel, PhD

The first time I was asked to give a presentation as part of an onsite interview, I thought, ‘Well this should be a cake walk – I’ll just redo my defense presentation.’ I didn’t get the job. And I knew that mid-way through my presentation. To start, they had only scheduled 30 minutes for my presentation, yet the one I had prepared was an hour. I ended up speed talking my way through the entire thing. Mistake number one. Mistake number two was not appealing to my audience. My presentation was highly technical, but my audience included people from R&D,…

The PhD Cheat Sheet For Conquering An Onsite Interview

The PhD Cheat Sheet For Conquering An Onsite Interview

By: Isaiah Hankel, PhD

When I was offered my first onsite interview, I was elated. But that elation quickly turned into panic. I had no idea what to expect. I had heard about other colleague’s interviewing experiences, but they all seemed so different. Some were in panel interviews, some had back-to-back one-on-one interviews, others had presentations, while others had a combination of all the above. I didn’t even know where to start in my preparation. So, I did what many PhDs do. I memorized verbatim answers to a handful of interview questions. I even reread my thesis to make sure I remembered every last…

6 Ways To Crush The Competition During Your Next  Video Interview

6 Ways To Crush The Competition During Your Next Video Interview

By: Isaiah Hankel, PhD

During my first industry job search, I was doing everything I could to prepare for in-person interviews. I got together with friends and colleagues, asked them to act as the interviewer and give me the tough questions. I asked them to critique my body language, my speech, and even how I planned to dress.   I really thought I was ready. So, after my first successful phone screen, I was completely sidelined when they told me the next steps included a video interview. A video interview? I wasn’t ready for this! At first, I prepared for it as I would…

Don't Flub The Phone Screen (8 Expert Tips For PhDs)

Don't Flub The Phone Screen (8 Expert Tips For PhDs)

By: Isaiah Hankel, PhD

I don’t think I’m alone when I say I dread phone calls. I’m willing to spend hours online trying to fix a problem just to avoid the 5-to-10-minute phone conversation it would require to solve it.    If this sounds familiar, I have some bad news: phone calls are unavoidable during your industry job search. In fact, its common for the first interaction between a job candidate and an employer to take place over the phone. This is called the phone screen. When I started my industry job search, I had no idea that phone screens were part of the…

6 Colossal Interview Blunders That PhDs Routinely Make

6 Colossal Interview Blunders That PhDs Routinely Make

By: Isaiah Hankel, PhD

When I started my industry job search, I thought interviews were merely a formality. Walking in the door, I was sure I already had the job. But so many times, I walked into an interview full of confidence and walked out feeling hopeless and confused. I was clearly botching my interviews, but I had no way of knowing where I was going wrong. When I aired my frustration to a friend of mine in talent acquisition, she told me what hiring managers really care about. It was then that I realized my blunders. It wasn’t that I was unqualified or…

Master The Informational Interview (And How To Land A Referral)

Master The Informational Interview (And How To Land A Referral)

By: Isaiah Hankel, PhD

By the time I started my industry job search, I was desperate. I was nearing the end of my PhD and I was consumed with what seemed like a million last-minute tasks – final experiments, last drafts, and defense presentations. I felt like I didn’t have the time to dedicate to my job search. And what little effort and time I did put into it was haphazard. My attempts involved repeatedly clicking the LinkedIn “Connect” button and uploading the same resume to any online job posting I could find. To make matters worse, I wasn’t even sure what job I…

5 Job Search Time Wasters That PhDs Should Stop Doing Immediately

5 Job Search Time Wasters That PhDs Should Stop Doing Immediately

By: Isaiah Hankel, PhD

Feeling discouraged with your job search strategy? Have you uploaded hundreds of resumes without hearing back from employers? Are you starting to think you are not cut out for an industry position? This happens to many PhDs at some point in their transition journey.  They don’t know how to execute a correct job search strategy. So they waste lots of time doing things that don’t yield any result. Then get discouraged. An industry job search is maddening. As PhDs we are never trained rigorously on how to do it in academia. Most PhDs are never trained on how to execute…

The Number One Reason PhDs Fail To Get Hired In Industry

The Number One Reason PhDs Fail To Get Hired In Industry

By: Isaiah Hankel, PhD

Today, I want to talk about the number one reason you are not being hired. You might think it’s because you are overqualified or underqualified for your target position. Or that you just can’t get hired because you lack industry experience. But the number one reason you are not getting hired is because you are invisible to industry hiring managers and recruiters. They simply don’t know who you are or the value you bring to the table. Understanding and accepting this should encourage you to change the way that you approach your job search.  Only then will you increase your…

Stuck And Purposeless In Academia? Here's What To Do

Stuck And Purposeless In Academia? Here's What To Do

By: Isaiah Hankel, PhD

Feeling purposeless and stuck? Every PhD will reach a point in their academic career where they have to reconnect with their purpose. Maybe you realize that you are not doing what you are doing for the right reasons. That you are working towards some else’s goal. Maybe you feel that achievements like a new publication or the title of “Doctor” are some sort of carrot that you have to chase without having a clear end in sight. This is especially true at the end of your academic career, where you have spent years working towards your PhD, or chasing endless…

Top Industry Career eBooks

Complete LinkedIn Guide For PhDs

Complete LinkedIn Guide For PhDs

Isaiah Hankel

The LinkedIn tips & strategies within have helped PhDs from every background get hired into top industry careers.

63 Best Industry Positions For PhDs

63 Best Industry Positions For PhDs

Isaiah Hankel, PhD & Arunodoy Sur, PhD

Learn about the best 63 industry careers for PhDs (regardless of your academic background). In this eBook, you will gain insight into the most popular, highest-paying jobs for PhDs – all of which will allow you to do meaningful work AND get paid well for it.

Complete LinkedIn Guide For PhDs

Complete LinkedIn Guide For PhDs

Isaiah Hankel

The LinkedIn tips & strategies within have helped PhDs from every background get hired into top industry careers.

Industry Resume Guide for PhDs

Industry Resume Guide for PhDs

Isaiah Hankel, PhD

Learn how to craft the perfect industry resume to attract employers. In this eBook for PhDs, you will get access to proven resume templates, learn how to structure your bullet points, and discover which keywords industry employers want to see most on PhD resumes.