Cheeky Logo
Ready To Transition Into Industry?
Apply To Book A Free Call With Our Transition Specialist Team

Your 2021 Job Search Strategy Is Probably Flawed. Here Are 8 Ways To Fix It

My job search strategy felt inadequate, it was a painful experience. I was perplexed.

My frustration knew no bounds, self pity and doubt shrouded me. I could not understand where I was going wrong. I spent days fixing my resume. Then, applied for one job at a time and waited to hear back from hiring managers and recruiters for 2 weeks before starting with the next job application.

I applied for every single job that came my way. The wait was painful, it was excruciating to bear the silence from the other end. 

Every moment I questioned myself; why would such a situation befall me? Why were there no replies to my perfectly crafted resume and uploaded application?

To my surprise, a friend who was in a similar situation actually got interview calls and eventually an offer letter. I was bewildered, what was he doing differently? Was his profile better than mine? Or was it sheer luck? 

Unable to contain my curiosity, I finally asked him about it. He told me that he had a very  organized ‘job search strategy.’ Honestly, the term was initially Greek to me, but it made much sense after he explained it. He said that the job search strategy was a war plan to land the dream job wherein each step was assessed by their time/effort/impact priorities.

I followed the strategy closely and landed the job I had been hunting for.           

Flaws In The Job Search Strategy

Job searching is a multi-step process that requires a strategic approach;  you need to evaluate each step based on the time, effort, and impact that it has on the entire process. Not designing the job search strategy based on the time/effort/impact priorities is the biggest flaw in the workflow. To set up a successful job search strategy, you need to transition from the academic mindset to the industry one. You have to think like an industry professional. Priority setting is an important quality of industry professionals. 

1. Spending most of your time on writing your resume

Most PhDs have confessed to spending most of their time in this step of the job search. Writing and rewriting resumes has taken the biggest time share in the incorrect job search phenomena. Surprisingly, PhD forget to tailor their resumes during the long time spent on this step. You should always take your basic resume to showcase your skills with reference to each job description. Resumes also need to be updated with buzz keywords and made ATS friendly. Therefore, spending maximum time rewriting resumes is unwise.

2.  Limiting your job search to uploading applications online

Uploading job applications online is yet another step that PhDs fixated on. Having lived in academia for a long time, writing journal articles, PhDs think that is the work they do best. But merely limiting your job prospects to uploading applications is a very small step in the job search strategy. Especially during the current recession when the number of advertised jobs has significantly decreased; you need to approach this with an open mind as you browse the openings and realize that current opportunities would need a huge deal of personalization. Being that one applicant among several others is just like finding a needle in a haystack; it reduces your chances of getting hired steeply.

3.  Going after one job lead at a time 

Pursuing one job at a time is a characteristic of academic PhDs that brings them to the Set-Up-To-Fail Syndrome. It’s a huge waste of precious time where you give other candidates a major time advantage. Pretty much like the hare and the turtle, except the turtle loses here. Before getting regular interviews, you need to adjust your expectations and strategies. PhDs need to understand that hiring managers and recruiters are not waiting to answer them and every company has a different hiring process, one may have an immediate job requirement, other may not have a rejection response. Hence, if you wait on one job process to complete before applying for another one, you will lose a lot of time you could spend on pursuing other leads.  

4. Waiting for hiring managers and recruiters to contact you

Engineering the cover letter and resume is quintessential for the job applying process as these are your first introduction to the hiring manager. But the expectation that they would find you and contact you as a potential candidate is far-fetched. If you are interested in being projected as the potential candidate in front of the recruiter the best way is to make an impression. Job search is a highly proactive process. In order to increase your chances of being seen by a recruiter or hiring manager, you need to practice reverse recruiting, which means that you need to reach out to the recruiter instead of waiting for them to reach out to you.

5. Asking people to help you get hired

Reaching out to industry contacts is pivotal but bluntly asking them to help you get hired is detrimental. Not only do you risk a denial from your contact, you can also end up burning an important bridge. A lot goes into building a rapport that can lead to a potential referral or an access to insider information. Asking people for jobs without adding value first or building up a relationship, may sever these ties for good. 

6. Creating a “bare bones” LinkedIn profile

Building up a candidate portfolio is indispensable since you are a stranger to the recruiter. Although your resume and cover letter serve as the initial introduction, most recruiters will scrutinize your LinkedIn profile to gauge your potential and have an insight into your professional self. 

Afterall, LinkedIn is a platform where you can portray yourself as the top candidate showcasing your skills, highlighting your accomplishments, tagging yourself with the relevant keywords . How well you present yourself gives them an idea about your productivity, creativity, and potential. Therefore, if you don’t plan on making the most out of your LinkedIn profile, it’s better to not have one. 

7. Not knowing where to start in the job search

Being a clueless PhD conceivably harms your chances of getting hired in an industry position. It’s important to build yourself for success rather than for failure. Most candidates don’t even create a job search strategy as they don’t know where to start. It is just like in a PhD; if you don’t set a goal, workout the experimental design, chalk out the limitations and strengths, you won’t be able to efficiently manage the time and resources and be productive. In this case, you will end up losing jobs.

8. Constantly violating industry social norms 

After passing all the hurdles and finally getting an offer, PhDS are already so exhausted that they presume negotiating the offer will further enrage the recruiters. As in academia, they vow not to further trouble the boss with requirements and are instead ready to start performing. Well, this is considered a violation of the social norms. Recruiters want you to negotiate, that is how they fathom your eagerness and interest in their job opening. 

8 Ways To Fix Your Flawed Job Search Strategy

The entire job search process is actually a sequence of steps, a specified protocol and not a random mix and match of steps. Designing a job search strategy requires allocating time and effort based on their impact on the overall process. It is said that winners don’t do different things, they just do things differently. Having the right job strategy matters when it comes to landing your dream job. You need to reinvent your job search strategy.

Figure 1: Correct Job Search Strategy Based On Time/Effort/Impact Prioritization

1. Get your resume template done once

PhDs tend to devote a colossal portion of their job search to resume writing, which is a bad use of their time. Instead, you should make a template and spend minimum time targeting your template for each individual job. Resume warrants mentioning any milestones, outcomes that you are trying to achieve, how can you display industry caliber, what value can you add to the industry? You need to target these achievements based on every job posting. 

Dedicate only some time in a week to make the template. A good resume is not good enough to get you a job but a bad resume can keep you from getting the job. Spend most of your time networking and following up on new networking contacts in order to build professional relationships and get job referrals. A referral can be as simple as asking someone to pass along your resume after a conversation, but it pushes your candidature to the top of HR’s list. 

2. Realize 80% of jobs are never posted online 

PhDs spend the least amount of their time networking. Even though statistics have shown most hires are done through networking. A major share of the jobs are not posted online, so they are only available to those who network. 

You should always research available jobs through online networks and informational interviews. Find industry contacts, set up informational interviews, add potential value to your contacts, and build a relationship to the level where you are comfortable enough to ask for reference or information. 

Companies spend a lot of money hiring and training new recruits, so high employee turnover is detrimental to the company.  Companies prefer to hire through referrals because employee retention increases to almost 46% and referred hires have faster training and onboarding processes. Hence, it is extremely important to overcome your introverted personality and focus on finding potential contacts. The information they give is golden.

3. The average PhD will need to pursue 30-40 job leads at once 

Going after multiple job leads instead of pursuing one job posting is a major advantage. Don’t wait to get a definitive response from an application to move to the next. 

To increase their chances of getting hired and reduce the time it takes to get there, every  job seeking PhD must pursue multiple job leads simultaneously. Also, it will divert you from being fixated on any hard rejection. 

You have to be ahead of the game and be cautious as well. It is immensely important to keep a track of every job that you applied for in a spreadsheet. Create a spreadsheet of jobs that you have applied for with all the referral you have got. A column for the jobs that you’re interested in, a column for the companies you’re interested, a column for the skill set that is needed, and a column for the referral. This is cardinal as it also keeps you updated about when to follow-up with your contact. 

4. You need to be reaching out to hiring managers and recruiters

Job search demands you to be proactive. Reverse recruiting techniques give a candidate the power  to be their own recruiter. Hiring Managers and recruiters may not find you; but you can  find the recruiter of your desired company. Locate the recruiter using email, google, twitter, or try AeroLeads’s LeadFinder. 

Then, reach out to them through email. You already possess the solid skills, you just need to be your own advocate. Reach out through LinkedIn or call the company HR department directly. Once you have personally shown interest, they will value your candidature more.

5. Don’t ask people to help you get hired for free

Don’t send desperate messages or unsolicited requests to people to help you get hired. This reflects poorly on your profile. Instead, ask people already working in industry how they got hired. Elevate their credibility and show appreciation by asking informational interview questions like: 

What do you enjoy most about your current position?

What are the biggest challenges, where do you see yourself moving next

This is more likely to lead them in to asking you, “what about you? where are you in your career/job search?” Which in turn leads to referrals. 

Stop asking for help and start asking for informational interviews. But understand the difference between networking and relationship-building. You must add value, try complementing their recent article, or their accomplishment, use the law of reciprocation. PhDs should value human connections and see them as long term investments to create meaningful professional relationships, not a short-term connection to only get hired.

6. It’s better NOT to have a LinkedIn profile at all than to have a “bare-bones” profile

LinkedIn is a powerful social media platform that supplies information to both job posters and job seekers. You are a stranger to the recruiter or HR but LinkedIn provides features that can not only introduce you but also professionally spotlight you as the best candidate for the role. 

LinkedIn keeps adding new features to better showcase your abilities. It is the best platform to connect with industry professionals and know their qualifications and achievements. Recruiters like to have a deeper insight into the potential candidates. These information are lucidly enlisted in your LinkedIn profile. Therefore, you need to complete your LinkedIn profile and turn on the button that lets recruiters and employers on LinkedIn Recruiter know that you are open to work.

7. You can’t hit a target you don’t set in the job search

Unless you set a goal, you can’t achieve it. Your job search strategy needs to be outlined & established for success. You need to identify which career path is right for you. It may be R&D, Med/Clinical Affairs, Information Aggregation; and then identify 2-3 job titles that are right for you. Then, work backwards to get hired into your dream job. 

Often, PhDs skip steps and focus majorly on preparing for interviews instead of networking or working on resumes. Searching on Google for interview tips, trying to prepare for job interviews proves futile because interviews are highly unpredictable and company/team-specific. 

8. Operate under industry social norms

You are currently operating under academic social norms such as being overly critical of yourself, others, and data; being overly suspicious of other people’s intentions; being passive and evasive. 

You need to start operating under industry social norms, such as following up, being more direct, negotiating, exchanging value, networking, adding value, and hoping to get value in return. Show enthusiasm and follow the industry trends and norms. Always negotiating is one such norm

Several PhDs just accept what they are given, this often stems from mistreatment at academia. They end up accepting offers fit for bachelors and masters as they hesitate to ask for more. PhDs must always negotiate with employers using a win-win attitude; not afraid to ask for what they are worth but also willing to make concessions. Companies want you to negotiate, flip your mindset: deal-making is a social norm, don’t violate it, ask an open-ended question. 

Concluding Remarks

To have the biggest impact on your job search, you have to distribute the time strategically among the steps. Flipp your job search strategy around and spend most of your time networking, then, creating a job search strategy and generating industry credibility. Stop spending precious time rewriting your resume and preparing for job interviews. Realize your worth as a PhD and set up the stage to conquer.

If you’re ready to start your transition into industry, you can apply to book a free Transition Call with our founder Isaiah Hankel, PhD or one of our Transition Specialists. Apply to book a Transition Call here.

Book a Transition Call
Get Free Job Search Content Weekly


Alejandra holds a PhD in genetics. After finishing her graduate studies, she followed her passion for closing the communication gap between scientific researchers and the general public. Currently, as vice-president of development at Cheeky Scientist, she produces content that helps PhDs find success outside academia.

Alejandra Viviescas, PhD

Similar Articles

5 Tough But Common Interview Questions For Research-Based Jobs

5 Tough But Common Interview Questions For Research-Based Jobs

By: Isaiah Hankel, PhD

“I can’t get hired because of my technical skills.” “I’m nervous about the technical questions.” This is what many PhDs obsess over before interviewing for a research role.  The problem is that interviewers are rarely going to ask highly specific technical questions, even for research-based roles.  I had a PhD who was up for an interview at Baxter and told me that they appreciated the advice, but because it’s Baxter they know the interview will be mostly technical.  “Like what?” I asked. “Do you think you’re going to have to create a buffer in front of them?” “Are they going…

Adjunct, Postdoc, Or Amazon Warehouse Worker: Where PhDs With No Plan End Up

Adjunct, Postdoc, Or Amazon Warehouse Worker: Where PhDs With No Plan End Up

By: Isaiah Hankel, PhD

My PhD story is a cautionary tale.  I got my PhD against the backdrop of today’s contracting skilled, or “white-collar” job market.  Armed with my doctorate and an unwavering passion for research and academia, I had set my sights on a future brimming with intellectual pursuits.  Little did I know that the unpredictable twists of fate would lead me down a path I detested—donning the uniform of an Amazon warehouse worker. This is not a slight against those I currently work with. It’s just not what I thought my years and years of PhD-level training would bring me.  Sadly, after…

Scam Job Posts Versus Ghost Job Listings: A Guide For PhDs

Scam Job Posts Versus Ghost Job Listings: A Guide For PhDs

By: Isaiah Hankel, PhD

“I’ve applied to hundreds of job postings.” “Using the same resume?” I asked. “No, I targeted every resume. I’ve heard nothing back. In some cases I was sent a rejection email within the hour. What’s happening?!”“Ghost job listings.” I replied.  “Like fake jobs? Scams? I had a friend who applied to a job online and entered their private info and got hacked after. Like this?” “No, though that happens. Ghost job listings are from real companies but these companies have no intention of actually filling these jobs anytime soon …or at all.” “Why would they do this? What’s the point?”…

How To Get Hired In 3 Months Or Less When You Have A PhD (5 Action Steps)

How To Get Hired In 3 Months Or Less When You Have A PhD (5 Action Steps)

By: Isaiah Hankel, PhD

I had a client named Sarah years ago who needed to get hired in less than 60 days.  She was very concerned, and rightly so, that this wasn’t possible. She had her own reasons why she had to get hired so quickly, as everyone does. There were family obligations she had to pay off. She had been unemployed for a few months at this point. And she was about to lose her visa. This was an urgent, uncomfortable situation to say the least.  When I first talked to Sarah, she was frantic. She couldn’t keep a thought in her head…

How PhDs Can Find The Best Fit Company To Work For

How PhDs Can Find The Best Fit Company To Work For

By: Isaiah Hankel, PhD

When I started my job search, I was obsessed with finding the right job title. I wanted to make sure that I got into a job that was a good fit for me. So I scoured the internet for jobs that sounded interesting. By that I mean I would read a job posting, play out scenarios in my head of working in the role, and then based on what I imagined, would apply to the job, or not.  This was a disastrous strategy.  First, job titles are so variable and numerous that I was lost in a sea of phrases…

4 Ways To Give Your Social Selling Index A Big Boost

4 Ways To Give Your Social Selling Index A Big Boost

By: Isaiah Hankel, PhD

Growing up, my parents had an adage for everything. And there was one I heard more than any other by far: Nothing worth having ever came easy. These words of wisdom were a lousy rebuttal for the injustices of childhood, but they became the mantra that got me through graduate school.  Maybe that’s why I regarded anything “easy” as weak, lazy, and average – all dirty words in my book. And, without knowing what LinkedIn was really about, I wrote it off as just that: an easy way for lazy people to try and find a job. It was, I…

10 Gotcha Interview Questions That Derail PhDs

10 Gotcha Interview Questions That Derail PhDs

By: Isaiah Hankel, PhD

There are hundreds of interview questions I’ve heard in the last 10 years. Thousands, actually. PhDs report back to me from the business end of their industry interviews a dozen, two dozen times a day. They ask for coaching on standard questions that you’ve probably been asked yourself in industry interviews: “Tell me what makes you the best fit for this job?”  “Where do you see yourself in five years?”  “What’s your biggest weakness?” I’ve also met with PhDs post-interview who tell me they were stumped by some really off-the-wall questions. Head-scratchers like: “How would your greatest enemy describe you?”…

Does Your PhD Resume Spell A Bad Culture Fit?

Does Your PhD Resume Spell A Bad Culture Fit?

By: Isaiah Hankel, PhD

One of the biggest reasons that I left academia was the constant negativity.  Instead of collaboration, I was pitted against my fellow PhDs. The system forced us to compete against one another. I couldn’t look to my advisors for support either. It was more trouble than it was worth to even get them to make time, and in the end, their “advice” was little more than common sense. And that’s to say nothing of the wrath I’d face if I picked the wrong time to speak up or advocate for my research. I persisted, though, and looked forward to applying…

3 Entry-Level PhD Jobs Pay Six Figures A Year

3 Entry-Level PhD Jobs Pay Six Figures A Year

By: Isaiah Hankel, PhD

I was determined to stay in academia… until I wasn’t.  It took almost six years for me to reach the conclusion that academia just wasn’t for me.  My PhD defense was just a few months away, and I can’t lie: I was literally willing myself to stick it out. But what about after that? Professorship had been the goal for me before I ever even enrolled in college. It had been my dream. I had absolutely no idea what to do if it wasn’t going to teach. I knew what I didn’t want: I didn’t want to be tethered to…

Top Industry Career eBooks

63 Best Industry Positions For PhDs

63 Best Industry Positions For PhDs

Isaiah Hankel, PhD & Arunodoy Sur, PhD

Learn about the best 63 industry careers for PhDs (regardless of your academic background). In this eBook, you will gain insight into the most popular, highest-paying jobs for PhDs – all of which will allow you to do meaningful work AND get paid well for it.

Complete LinkedIn Guide For PhDs

Complete LinkedIn Guide For PhDs

Isaiah Hankel

The LinkedIn tips & strategies within have helped PhDs from every background get hired into top industry careers.

Industry Resume Guide for PhDs

Industry Resume Guide for PhDs

Isaiah Hankel, PhD

Learn how to craft the perfect industry resume to attract employers. In this eBook for PhDs, you will get access to proven resume templates, learn how to structure your bullet points, and discover which keywords industry employers want to see most on PhD resumes.